{
  "version": "coding-calibration-0.1",
  "baselineEdition": "PE-2026.10-v3",
  "baselineSha256": "b8afe90378c65ac72405744730d027105602b9de0bbc4178e060ce7f2364eeca",
  "status": "Worked examples for future coder training; not completed blinded reliability testing.",
  "instructions": [
    "Code entity scope and source access before theme/anchor.",
    "Separate eligibility, theme assignment, implementation status and evidence specificity.",
    "Record U when qualifying support is missing; do not infer absent capability.",
    "Use an anchor only for the specific supported interpretation; score maximum per theme.",
    "Escalate disagreement with exact passage and rationale; preserve original and accepted decisions.",
    "These examples reproduce existing coding and can expose ambiguities; they do not validate the rubric."
  ],
  "examples": [
    {
      "dimension": "ai-core",
      "codingLesson": "A named in-progress integration is not routine production. An inaccessible general ambition cannot qualify.",
      "positive": {
        "id": "LOG-001",
        "claim": "Emirates Airport Services reports a launched AI system for aircraft-turnaround analysis and resource optimization.",
        "level": 2,
        "eligible": true,
        "status": "deployed",
        "rationale": "Explicit launched internal airport-operations practice; evaluation and deployment coverage are undisclosed.",
        "url": "https://www.emirates.com/media-centre/forsatek-2025-offers-platform-for-high-impact-scalable-innovation/",
        "locator": "AI-powered solutions paragraph; fully launched Airport Services initiative",
        "claimSha256": "0b255dabfbf5ff004f042aef66c536f3a043224766bb46c80bd01be596732d8c"
      },
      "boundary": {
        "id": "LOG-021",
        "claim": "Milaha reports beginning AI integration at its logistics centre in 2025 as it moves toward more automated warehousing.",
        "level": 1,
        "eligible": true,
        "status": "pilot",
        "rationale": "Named AI integration activity at an internal site; current wording does not clearly establish production operation.",
        "url": "https://www.milaha.com/sites/default/files/2026-02/Milaha-Annual-Report-2025-EN.pdf",
        "locator": "PDF page 18, printed pages 30-31, Digital Transformation",
        "claimSha256": "12834203f145f88bdd4b167167a5422c96df3d868f4230e4dd8c10c7801f80a4"
      },
      "excludedClaim": {
        "id": "LOG-037",
        "claim": "Indexed town-hall coverage mentions ambitions involving AI alongside other digital technologies.",
        "level": null,
        "eligible": false,
        "status": "aspiration",
        "rationale": "Excluded: inaccessible source and generic ambition do not establish a named internal AI practice. Exclusion: Explicit extraction-stage exclusion retained. No qualifying AI-specific operating anchor retained. Complete readable source support not established; indexed-only evidence cannot score.",
        "url": "https://www.bahrainairport.bh/corporate/news/bahrain-airport-company-bac-hosts-journey-to-excellence-town-hall-and-launches-the-tamayouz-programme",
        "locator": "Search-indexed article passage; full page unavailable",
        "exclusionReasons": [
          "Explicit extraction-stage exclusion retained.",
          "No qualifying AI-specific operating anchor retained.",
          "Complete readable source support not established; indexed-only evidence cannot score."
        ],
        "claimSha256": "c47decc68f0a6adc6191afe78ae4e852ed5a71f1f800c3ca071c3d863eb9e2aa"
      }
    },
    {
      "dimension": "workforce",
      "codingLesson": "Onboarding or course participation supplies disclosure detail; it does not demonstrate active use or competence.",
      "positive": {
        "id": "LOG-004",
        "claim": "More than 2,000 Group IT staff had joined its AI gateway by August 2026.",
        "level": 3,
        "eligible": true,
        "status": "deployed",
        "rationale": "Primary Emirates page paragraphs115–116 explicitly reports IT onboarding count. Retain level3 for bounded workforce coverage; do not infer active usage or all employees.",
        "url": "https://www.emirates.com/media-centre/catalysing-the-next-wave-of-innovation-at-the-emirates-group-forsatek-2026-concludes-successfully/",
        "locator": "ARRIVE and AI gateway paragraphs near article end",
        "claimSha256": "b67a614a4fd3f8ca2a7b96cfd1281a5032a2e7ad01be91f5a982ed4d99a9c138"
      },
      "boundary": {
        "id": "LOG-003",
        "claim": "The Group announced enterprise ChatGPT access and AI-literacy programmes for employees.",
        "level": 1,
        "eligible": true,
        "status": "aspiration",
        "rationale": "Specific internal rollout commitment; announcement uses forward-looking implementation language.",
        "url": "https://www.emirates.com/media-centre/emirates-group-collaborates-with-openai-to-accelerate-ai-adoption-and-innovation/",
        "locator": "Enterprise ChatGPT, training and internal champion network paragraphs",
        "claimSha256": "50f4f5c85791b6612543d774addd5df2ca0201ea6341cdf31142dd13698e8808"
      },
      "excludedClaim": {
        "id": "LOG-024",
        "claim": "The collaboration includes a planned employee Skill Boost programme.",
        "level": null,
        "eligible": false,
        "status": "aspiration",
        "rationale": "Excluded: the retrieved passage does not establish AI-specific employee curriculum or completed participation. Exclusion: Explicit extraction-stage exclusion retained. No qualifying AI-specific operating anchor retained.",
        "url": "https://milaha.com/en/news-and-media/milaha-enhances-data-ai-solutions-google-cloud",
        "locator": "Skill Boost programme paragraph",
        "exclusionReasons": [
          "Explicit extraction-stage exclusion retained.",
          "No qualifying AI-specific operating anchor retained."
        ],
        "claimSha256": "fa7af41880f65bb9892fe5faefa3f04a3387d78c75a657b4ebfdf54b549132d6"
      }
    },
    {
      "dimension": "ecosystem",
      "codingLesson": "Retain specific partner delivery commitments at 1; recover exact source content before admitting indexed-only evidence.",
      "positive": {
        "id": "LOG-019",
        "claim": "Qatar Airways Cargo staff contributed to the supplier implementation and refinement of CARGOSTACK Optimiser.",
        "level": 2,
        "eligible": true,
        "status": "deployed",
        "rationale": "Named staff/supplier collaboration in an implemented internal AI operating system.",
        "url": "https://www.wiremind.io/blog/qatar-airways-cargo-cargostack-optimiser",
        "locator": "Joint-development and airline-team contribution paragraphs",
        "claimSha256": "40b567a03ad01b739e523b19c7e8677f47ca69bc7db6397eeded6a25d420ff9a"
      },
      "boundary": {
        "id": "LOG-013",
        "claim": "Bahri and Aventra announced a maritime data-orchestration platform intended to support machine learning and AI.",
        "level": 1,
        "eligible": true,
        "status": "aspiration",
        "rationale": "Named internal AI-related platform programme with partner delivery role.",
        "url": "https://www.bahri.sa/en/news-insights/news-insight/2022/bahri-partners-with-aventra-group-to-accelerate-digital-transformation-journey/",
        "locator": "Partnership and platform-function paragraphs",
        "claimSha256": "4689b01a3dd5bb39316dd7b6be9dc3e1db32bbdf0807e92343c41bb69df33bb1"
      },
      "excludedClaim": {
        "id": "bank-nbb-01",
        "claim": "NBB's ARRAY agreement specifies assessment of its technology footprint and planned NLP/GenAI integration.",
        "level": null,
        "eligible": false,
        "status": "aspiration",
        "rationale": "Original official URL inaccessible during review; indexed-only passage cannot score under release protocol. A separate directly readable annual report may support another claim. Exclusion: No qualifying AI-specific operating anchor retained. Excluded by independent source-review pass. Complete readable source support not established; indexed-only evidence cannot score.",
        "url": "https://nbbonline.com/news/17533/",
        "locator": "Planned assessment and NLP/GenAI collaboration",
        "exclusionReasons": [
          "No qualifying AI-specific operating anchor retained.",
          "Excluded by independent source-review pass.",
          "Complete readable source support not established; indexed-only evidence cannot score."
        ],
        "claimSha256": "0968eb8b3e1ae026cc694ee021bc1c9f3b41b432ba96a362c30b170cb71d5b3d"
      }
    },
    {
      "dimension": "interfaces",
      "codingLesson": "Technical detail cannot promote a pilot to implementation; distinguish service workflow integration from a proposed customer channel.",
      "positive": {
        "id": "LOG-016",
        "claim": "The AI-driven TOS+ digital twin at Jafza uses real-time data for terminal actions including gate opening and maintenance alerts.",
        "level": 3,
        "eligible": true,
        "status": "deployed",
        "rationale": "Reopened DP World CTO account paragraphs107–110: AI suite, Jafza digital twin, gate opening and maintenance alerts. Retain3 for internal interface mechanism; no high-stakes autonomous authority inferred.",
        "url": "https://www.dpworld.com/en/insights/how-ai-is-transforming-global-trade-possibilities",
        "locator": "Digital twin and CARGOES TOS+ paragraphs",
        "claimSha256": "bca37e6475d01f875c10dc7d9fb94d0da501f73e6f093cb8c89b442ddca882fb"
      },
      "boundary": {
        "id": "BAPCOU02",
        "claim": "The implemented model lets engineers test scenarios and choose network setpoints.",
        "level": 1,
        "eligible": true,
        "status": "pilot",
        "rationale": "Downgraded from proposed 3: engineering scenario and setpoint support is described for the initial field-tested model. Routine post-test use is unestablished; preserve decision-support pilot at 1, with no autonomous-control inference.",
        "url": "https://www.automation.com/article/geminus-ai-bapco-energies-slb-physics-native-ai-bahrain-energy-infrastructure",
        "locator": "Engineering what-if paragraph",
        "claimSha256": "348a210ceec0aa5a2644e57f48ecb2f5357f4205ecb1fcd90c3ed054ce4d514f"
      },
      "excludedClaim": {
        "id": "LOG-027",
        "claim": "The TCS agreement proposes AI-enabled website, app and chatbot changes for passengers.",
        "level": null,
        "eligible": false,
        "status": "aspiration",
        "rationale": "Excluded: proposed customer channels alone do not demonstrate internal AI operating capability. Exclusion: Explicit extraction-stage exclusion retained. No qualifying AI-specific operating anchor retained.",
        "url": "https://www.tcs.com/who-we-are/newsroom/press-release/jazeera-airways-partners-with-tcs-to-power-ai-led-transformation-reimagine-digital-customer-experience",
        "locator": "Digital customer experience and AI-led architecture paragraphs",
        "exclusionReasons": [
          "Explicit extraction-stage exclusion retained.",
          "No qualifying AI-specific operating anchor retained."
        ],
        "claimSha256": "799caa711864b0ed89ae561988225e7587b2f184bc670b555384907d05b4544b"
      }
    },
    {
      "dimension": "lineage",
      "codingLesson": "A described logging architecture can qualify as a company assertion, but is not an inspected decision trace. No eligible level-1 lineage example exists in this frozen corpus.",
      "positive": {
        "id": "LOG-005",
        "claim": "ARRIVE records intent, scope, risk, evidence and decisions in AI-assisted software delivery.",
        "level": 3,
        "eligible": true,
        "status": "deployed",
        "rationale": "Primary Emirates paragraph115 describes records for intent, scope, risk, evidence and decisions in the software lifecycle. Retain3 for this IT lineage mechanism, not enterprise-wide traceability.",
        "url": "https://www.emirates.com/media-centre/catalysing-the-next-wave-of-innovation-at-the-emirates-group-forsatek-2026-concludes-successfully/",
        "locator": "ARRIVE software-engineering framework paragraph",
        "claimSha256": "9b33c371d45d272513cf3bdb957cf191801e14a686e183164c4310f4dce04e04"
      },
      "boundary": {
        "id": "bank-emirates-nbd-03",
        "claim": "Leap supplies agent audit logging, observability, prompt management and model-governance controls.",
        "level": 3,
        "eligible": true,
        "status": "deployed",
        "rationale": "Leap page describes default audit, observability and model controls on internal platform. This is a company assertion, not an inspected decision log.",
        "url": "https://www.emiratesnbd.com/en/innovation/insights/why-banks-should-build-their-own-agentic-ai-framework",
        "locator": "Leap platform controls; enterprise abstraction",
        "claimSha256": "1d24c7a5e8873b9c792d18ea1c9d6a27bbf0fe2e9c747d2e6ea380b929a5ba1a"
      },
      "excludedClaim": {
        "id": "HLT-023",
        "claim": "PureCS describes AI infrastructure decisions reflecting data residency and regulatory requirements.",
        "level": null,
        "eligible": false,
        "status": "deployed",
        "rationale": "Infrastructure residency rationale does not establish data lineage or traceability. Preserve raw exclusion. Exclusion: New claim has no explicit accepted review decision. Explicit extraction-stage exclusion retained. No qualifying AI-specific operating anchor retained. Excluded by independent source-review pass.",
        "url": "https://purehealth.ae/wp-content/uploads/2026/03/PureHealth_Integrated-Annual-Report_2025_EN.pdf",
        "locator": "PDF40/printed76–77, AI Factory",
        "exclusionReasons": [
          "New claim has no explicit accepted review decision.",
          "Explicit extraction-stage exclusion retained.",
          "No qualifying AI-specific operating anchor retained.",
          "Excluded by independent source-review pass."
        ],
        "claimSha256": "39cd5d611f3cc21ea082111885699f5a35fb3bd44fc9dcad181bc69811eeb12d"
      }
    },
    {
      "dimension": "experimentation",
      "codingLesson": "A trial can qualify at 1; described model iteration can qualify at 3 without proving independent validation or a causal effect. No excluded experimentation claim exists in this frozen corpus.",
      "positive": {
        "id": "LOG-018",
        "claim": "The cargo team and Wiremind tested and iterated multiple machine-learning approaches during model validation.",
        "level": 3,
        "eligible": true,
        "status": "deployed",
        "rationale": "Reopened Wiremind paragraph106: company-team implementation input and explicit multiple ML approaches tested and iterated. Retain3 under evaluation-process anchor; no criteria, effect size or rigorous independent validation established.",
        "url": "https://www.wiremind.io/blog/qatar-airways-cargo-cargostack-optimiser",
        "locator": "Collaboration and model-development/validation paragraphs",
        "claimSha256": "8ad5061e10a3ca54c4f00f177dbc245f9eee6bb86ac2670188f0f89b0a16ff37"
      },
      "boundary": {
        "id": "LOG-002",
        "claim": "Emirates Engineering is trialling AI and computer vision to identify engine parts.",
        "level": 1,
        "eligible": true,
        "status": "pilot",
        "rationale": "Named internal AI trial; no production deployment established.",
        "url": "https://www.emirates.com/media-centre/forsatek-2025-offers-platform-for-high-impact-scalable-innovation/",
        "locator": "AI-powered solutions paragraph; engineering trials",
        "claimSha256": "689844c25f58aa7f77cdb7b18d6f4d240169c230100f974e73790b5768a61296"
      },
      "excludedClaim": null,
      "excludedInterpretation": {
        "basedOnClaimId": "LOG-018",
        "unsupportedReading": "The supplier account proves independent causal validation of enterprise-wide performance.",
        "reason": "The accepted record describes model testing and iteration, without independent causal validation. This excludes an interpretation, not the released claim."
      }
    },
    {
      "dimension": "autonomy",
      "codingLesson": "A live decision mechanism must retain its stated authority boundary; projected workload reduction cannot establish deployed authority.",
      "positive": {
        "id": "bank-cbq-04",
        "claim": "The investor presentation identifies AI-optimised credit-limit increases as live.",
        "level": 2,
        "eligible": true,
        "status": "deployed",
        "rationale": "Investor slide PDF index8 explicitly labels credit-limit automation live. Readable www.cbq.qa alternate; bare domain retrieval failed.",
        "url": "https://www.cbq.qa/-/media/project/cbq/cbqwebsite/documents/financial-reports-en/2025/q4/investor-presentation---fy-2025.pdf",
        "locator": "Strategy slide 9, Accelerating our AI Journey",
        "claimSha256": "55f2e457486c12bce606bb2f56a2ba79e90f1e9796bdf12457ed7fb14bc24093"
      },
      "boundary": {
        "id": "TEL-012",
        "claim": "e& UAE and TM Forum published a roadmap towards Level 4/5 autonomous networks with human governance and policy controls.",
        "level": 1,
        "eligible": true,
        "status": "aspiration",
        "rationale": "Specific technical transformation roadmap.",
        "url": "https://www.eand.com/en/news/22-06-26-eand-tm-strategic-blueprint.html",
        "locator": "Main release, roadmap paragraphs",
        "claimSha256": "564675156ecf92088d48036f78e372e0ac9e4baff695c0359bdc1c0857ac2559"
      },
      "excludedClaim": {
        "id": "HLT-015",
        "claim": "The AIRIS-TB study estimates potential automation of80% of screening work.",
        "level": null,
        "eligible": false,
        "status": "planned",
        "rationale": "Potential workload automation does not establish implemented decision authority. Preserve raw exclusion. Exclusion: New claim has no explicit accepted review decision. Explicit extraction-stage exclusion retained. No qualifying AI-specific operating anchor retained. Excluded by independent source-review pass.",
        "url": "https://m42.ae/media-resources/news/m42-announces-breakthrough-results-for-its-ai-powered-tuberculosis-screening/",
        "locator": "Automation potential paragraph",
        "exclusionReasons": [
          "New claim has no explicit accepted review decision.",
          "Explicit extraction-stage exclusion retained.",
          "No qualifying AI-specific operating anchor retained.",
          "Excluded by independent source-review pass."
        ],
        "claimSha256": "f76c11719a4cf46c705bdaed183d42bdfc7d7d8e9fb96239cc482525b1ba13e7"
      }
    },
    {
      "dimension": "knowledge",
      "codingLesson": "Named guidance under development is a commitment; network observability alone does not demonstrate organisational knowledge management.",
      "positive": {
        "id": "LOG-034",
        "claim": "FalconEye combines flight, passenger, crew and other operating information for executive questions.",
        "level": 2,
        "eligible": true,
        "status": "deployed",
        "rationale": "Named implemented internal knowledge interface unifies multiple operating information domains.",
        "url": "https://techcommunity.microsoft.com/blog/azure-ai-foundry-blog/public-preview-voice-native-agents-in-microsoft-foundry/4502756",
        "locator": "Gulf Air FalconEye customer example",
        "claimSha256": "d96853f64c5dc57b6943d119b6ae3dabb717e9fe3add646f4951bc7b65dd455a"
      },
      "boundary": {
        "id": "MAN-ALBA06",
        "claim": "Alba describes a Code of Conduct chatbot designed to guide employees on conduct-policy questions.",
        "level": 1,
        "eligible": true,
        "status": "planned",
        "rationale": "Specific conduct-policy chatbot is described as designed for guidance; ongoing operational use is not unambiguously evidenced.",
        "url": "https://www.albasmelter.com/uploads/albayan2026_q1.pdf",
        "locator": "Physical25, printed48–49, Code of Conduct Chatbot subsection",
        "claimSha256": "14b4e1435f9c6c5f582aaa22703595be63fc96df5f1186c0e2136da94a588549"
      },
      "excludedClaim": {
        "id": "TEL-035",
        "claim": "stc Bahrain assurance combines topology discovery, cross-domain fault correlation and predictive analytics.",
        "level": null,
        "eligible": false,
        "status": "deployed",
        "rationale": "Network observability does not establish organizational knowledge-management capability. Exclusion: No qualifying AI-specific operating anchor retained.",
        "url": "https://www.stc.com.bh/media-center/template?id=4346",
        "locator": "AI assurance mechanism paragraph",
        "exclusionReasons": [
          "No qualifying AI-specific operating anchor retained."
        ],
        "claimSha256": "4638bd449d15c4806cd52ecf80dae4b6e6ab0c0af03a3ae6f9a274dadcceff1a"
      }
    },
    {
      "dimension": "governance",
      "codingLesson": "Applied AI-specific responsibility differs from an unfinished framework or ordinary security and record access.",
      "positive": {
        "id": "LOG-006",
        "claim": "ARRIVE embeds governance and human accountability in Group IT AI-assisted engineering.",
        "level": 3,
        "eligible": true,
        "status": "deployed",
        "rationale": "Primary Emirates paragraph115 names ARRIVE and governance/human-accountability plus the structured delivery record. Retain3 for described IT operating framework, not proof of governance effectiveness.",
        "url": "https://www.emirates.com/media-centre/catalysing-the-next-wave-of-innovation-at-the-emirates-group-forsatek-2026-concludes-successfully/",
        "locator": "ARRIVE paragraph; governance and human accountability",
        "claimSha256": "86f149e66c93eb38ef0d504a2d4d0a673ec6a19abdd7b7624bf6e339592c362e"
      },
      "boundary": {
        "id": "bank-al-rajhi-06",
        "claim": "Al Rajhi states its formal AI governance framework remains under development.",
        "level": 1,
        "eligible": true,
        "status": "aspiration",
        "rationale": "Specific AI framework in development; not deployed governance.",
        "url": "https://www.alrajhibank.com.sa/ir25/corporate_governance/data_privacy_and_information_management.html",
        "locator": "Opening section, paragraph beginning Both internal and external privacy policies",
        "claimSha256": "67e420da18c7fad1daeba0f57884b1fbce63a4308841ec1560ca505ac2edd12c"
      },
      "excludedClaim": {
        "id": "LOG-010",
        "claim": "The training system gives GACA access to training records and uses security roles.",
        "level": null,
        "eligible": false,
        "status": "deployed",
        "rationale": "Excluded: training-record access and ordinary system security do not establish AI-specific governance. Exclusion: Explicit extraction-stage exclusion retained. No qualifying AI-specific operating anchor retained.",
        "url": "https://www.microsoft.com/en/customers/story/1782079017420911107-saudia-academy-dynamics-365-customer-service-travel-and-transportation-en-saudi-arabia",
        "locator": "GACA audit access and security roles paragraphs",
        "exclusionReasons": [
          "Explicit extraction-stage exclusion retained.",
          "No qualifying AI-specific operating anchor retained."
        ],
        "claimSha256": "87fd1244ffc4eb2a77a860bab1366c70e7f1db01292eaaee2edc4720044acf36"
      }
    }
  ]
}